Student Outshines Master: A Full Circle Moment in South African Football

Vodacom Challenge - Manchester United v Kaizer Chiefs

CAPE TOWN, SOUTH AFRICA - JULY 18: Arthur Zwane and Patrice Evra in action during the Vodacom Challenge match between the Kaizer Chiefs and Manchester United at Newlands Stadium July 18, 2006 in Cape Town, South Africa Under Coach Mushin Etuğral. (Photo by Touchline/Getty Images)

By Qotoyi Xolani 

In a game where we saw the future of South African football with Emile Witbooi’s senior debut at only 16 years an equally significant storyline emerged—a student outshining his master. 

Arthur Zwane’s victory over his former coach, Muhsin Ertuğral, was more than just a tactical battle; it was a symbolic moment that highlighted the changing of the guard in South African football.

Zwane, who played under Ertuğral at Kaizer Chiefs, is now the head coach of AmaZulu FC. His team’s victory over Ertuğral’s Cape Town City is symbolic of how Zwane has not only developed as a coach but has also surpassed the expectations set by his mentor. 

This win is particularly poignant as it comes at a time when Zwane is proving himself in the South African football scene, despite the challenges he faced in the past.

A key part of the story lies in Zwane’s journey from being fired as Kaizer Chiefs’ head coach to now finding himself in a position of power with AmaZulu. When Zwane took over at AmaZulu, the club was struggling near the bottom of the league. Under his leadership, AmaZulu has steadily climbed up the ranks, now sitting in 5th place in the league standings. In contrast, Kaizer Chiefs, the club where Zwane spent most of his playing and coaching career, is currently languishing in 8th place.

Zwane’s victory over Ertuğral and his current success with AmaZulu is just one example of how former players-turned-coaches can shape the football landscape. His journey—from being dismissed by Kaizer Chiefs to now guiding AmaZulu to success—was not just about redemption but about surpassing expectations. It serves as a reminder that football is not only about players on the field but also the journey of those who shape and guide the next generation of talent.

As the football world continues to evolve, it’s clear that the line between student and master is fluid, with each generation of coaches bringing new ideas, innovations, and triumphs to the sport.